Important: These forums are for discussions between SkyDemon users. They are not routinely monitored by SkyDemon staff so any urgent issues should be sent directly to our Customer Support.

Different MSA on reverse legs


Author
Message
JanR
JanR
Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)Too Much Forum (4.3K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 40, Visits: 2.3K
Hi,

during planning I noticed, that the MSA ist different for identical but reversed legs.
e.g. BOT NDB to DOMEG shows only MSA 2.200, on the reversed leg (DOMEG => BOT)  it is 2.300. 
For the leg Essen to BOT (2.300) it is even 300 ft less on the reverse leg. Why?

(PC Version 3.6.0.0 & latest Android  Version)



Thanks & Regards
Jan
Reply
lhe
lhe
Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)Too Much Forum (15K reputation)
Group: Forum Members
Posts: 154, Visits: 445
Tim Dawson - 6/28/2016 4:18:35 PM
That isn't always a great solution. For example on a long leg, it would typically be quite undesirable to have the entire leg's MSA adjusted for one obstacle that is very much on the outside of a turn at one end. Although I do agree that it's a little unintuitive to have only one leg affected by it.

We can't do anything immediately about this as it's part of a core part of code that we have no plans to touch in the next couple of weeks (we're quite busy). I'm open to suggestions on this thread as to the best way to treat such obstacles, though, so we can address the issue in the best way possible.

On the contrary, it would be quite desirable! There is no difference between an obstacle being outside of a straight track and outside of a turn. If you set up SD to compute the MSA based on obstacles a certain distance from your track, it doesn't matter if you're on a straight line or in a turn. If anything, it is more critical in the turn since you don't have any course guidance in the turn itself.

If you have a long leg and there is a significant obstacle near one end which affects the whole leg, you can insert intermediate waypoints. Again no difference between turns and straight tracks.

Also, from a regulatory point of view, there is a minimum altitude for night VFR which is based on obstacles a certain distance away. This distance apply equally in turns as it does in when flying in a straight line.
GO

Merge Selected

Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...





Reading This Topic

Login

Explore
Messages
Mentions
Search